NHL

• The Bottom Line: Viewing the National Hockey League (NHL) not merely as a sports entity but as a collection of 32 government-sanctioned, local monopolies provides a masterclass in the value investing principles of economic moats, pricing power, and long-term predictable cash flows.
• Key Takeaways:
• What it is: From an investor's perspective, the NHL is a closed cartel of sports franchises, each possessing an immensely powerful, geographically-focused brand with a deeply loyal customer base.
• Why it matters: It serves as a perfect, real-world case study for understanding how intangible assets like brand loyalty and network effects create a powerful economic_moat that protects profits for decades.
• How to use it: As a mental model to evaluate other businesses, asking: “Does this company have the same kind of durable competitive advantage and pricing power as a major sports franchise?”

On the surface, the National Hockey League (NHL) is the world's premier professional ice hockey league. For millions of fans, it's a source of passion, community, and entertainment. But for a value investor, it's something far more interesting. Imagine a kingdom that has granted exclusive rights to 32 different lords to rule over 32 specific, valuable territories. No new lords can join without the unanimous consent of all the others, and none of the existing lords can be kicked out for poor performance. Each lord has a castle (the arena), a loyal populace (the fan base), and the exclusive right to sell the kingdom's most popular product (professional hockey) in their territory. That, in essence, is the business structure of the NHL. It's a closed league, meaning teams are permanent fixtures. Unlike European soccer leagues, there is no threat of relegation for finishing last. This structure creates incredible stability and predictability. The “business” of an NHL team isn't just selling tickets. It's a multi-faceted revenue machine built on:

• Media Rights: Multi-billion dollar, long-term contracts with broadcasters like ESPN and Warner Bros. Discovery in the U.S., and Rogers in Canada. This is predictable, guaranteed revenue shared among all the “lords.”
• Ticket Sales & Concessions: The direct revenue from fans attending games at the “castle.”
• Sponsorships: Companies paying millions to have their logos on the ice, the boards, and the jerseys.
• Merchandise: The sale of jerseys, hats, and other gear to a loyal populace that proudly displays their allegiance.

From a value investor's standpoint, the NHL is not a high-tech growth story. It's an old-world business model perfected for the modern age, built on the unshakable foundation of human passion and tribal loyalty.

“The key to investing is not assessing how much an industry is going to affect society, or how much it will grow, but rather determining the competitive advantage of any given company and, above all, the durability of that advantage. The products or services that have wide, sustainable moats around them are the ones that deliver rewards to investors.” - Warren Buffett

The NHL is a phenomenal teaching tool for a value investor because it brings several core, often abstract, concepts to life in a tangible way. While you can't easily buy shares in most NHL teams ¹⁾, understanding its business model sharpens your analytical skills for the companies you can invest in. 1. The Ultimate Economic Moat Benjamin Graham and Warren Buffett talk endlessly about the importance of a “moat”—a durable competitive advantage that protects a business from competitors, much like a moat protects a castle. The NHL's moat is vast and deep:

• Powerful Brands & Fan Loyalty: You cannot replicate the 100+ year history of the Montreal Canadiens or the Toronto Maple Leafs. This loyalty is often passed down through generations. A fan won't switch to a new, cheaper hockey league any more than they would switch families. This creates unwavering demand.
• Regulatory & Legal Barriers: The NHL operates as a legal cartel. It would be nearly impossible for a rival league to secure the best players, the national television deals, and the political backing to build arenas in major cities. This effectively locks out all meaningful competition.
• Network Effects: The league becomes more valuable as it grows. More teams create more interesting matchups, which draws more fans, which attracts larger media deals, which provides more money to attract the best players, creating a virtuous cycle.

2. Inherent Pricing_Power Pricing power is a company's ability to raise its prices without losing significant business. It's a key defense against inflation. NHL teams have it in spades. They can, and do, regularly increase ticket prices, and loyal fans continue to pay. Broadcasters engage in bidding wars, driving up the value of media rights. Sponsors pay more each year for premium placement. A business with true pricing power is a gem for a value investor. 3. Predictable, Long-Term Cash Flows Value investors abhor uncertainty. They seek businesses with understandable and predictable futures. The NHL's revenue streams are remarkably stable. The multi-year, multi-billion dollar media contracts are the bedrock of this stability. While a team's on-ice success may vary year to year, this foundational revenue is locked in, providing a floor for financial performance and allowing for rational long-term planning. 4. Scarcity and Intangible_Assets There are only 32 NHL franchises. This government-approved scarcity makes them incredibly valuable “trophy assets.” Their value isn't just in the cash they generate; it's in their status and rarity. This teaches a value investor that a company's intrinsic value is often far more than what's on the balance sheet. The brand, the history, the fan loyalty—these are intangible assets of immense, though unquantified, worth.

While you may not be buying an NHL team, you can apply the “Franchise Analysis” model to any potential stock investment. This means looking beyond the quarterly earnings reports and assessing the business as a durable, long-term franchise.

Here is a step-by-step method to apply the lessons from the NHL model to a publicly-traded company:

1. Step 1: Identify the Moat.
   • Ask: What protects this company from competition? Is it a powerful brand (like Coca-Cola)? A patent (like a pharmaceutical company)? A network effect (like Facebook)? High switching costs for customers (like a bank)? Or is it a government-granted monopoly (like a utility company, or an NHL team)? If you can't easily identify a strong, durable moat, be very cautious.
2. Step 2: Test for Pricing Power.
   • Look at the company's history. Has it been able to consistently raise prices over the last decade without losing market share? A company that can only grow by cutting prices is in a weak competitive position. A company that can pass on its own rising costs to customers (and then some) has the pricing power that value investors cherish.
3. Step 3: Analyze the Predictability of Revenue.
   • How much of the company's revenue is recurring or contractual? A software company with a subscription model has more predictable revenue than a construction company that relies on winning one-off projects. Look for long-term contracts, high customer retention rates, and products that are essential, not discretionary.
4. Step 4: Evaluate Management and Capital Allocation.
   • In the NHL, a good owner invests wisely in player development, a modern arena, and the fan experience for long-term success. A bad owner might overpay for aging stars in a desperate, ego-driven attempt to win now, mortgaging the future.
   • Similarly, for a stock, evaluate how management uses the company's cash. Are they reinvesting it in high-return projects? Are they buying back shares when they are undervalued? Or are they making foolish, overpriced acquisitions to build a personal empire?
5. Step 5: Insist on a Margin of Safety.
   • Even the best franchise can be a bad investment if you overpay. First, you must attempt to calculate the business's intrinsic_value. Then, you must demand a discount to that value before buying. For an NHL team, a risk might be a prolonged player strike or a decline in the sport's popularity. For any business, you must identify the risks and ensure the price you pay provides a cushion in case those risks materialize.

Let's use our “Franchise Analysis” model to compare two hypothetical beverage companies, applying the lessons from the NHL. Company A: “Legacy Cola Co.” (The “Original Six” Team) Company B: “Flash Energy Drink Inc.” (The “Expansion Team”)

This table shows how the mental model of a durable sports franchise can be directly applied to find high-quality, long-lasting businesses in the stock market.

• Clarity of the Moat Concept: There are few better or clearer examples of an economic moat than a major sports league. It makes an abstract concept feel real and understandable.
• Emphasis on Intangible Assets: Using the NHL model forces you to appreciate the immense financial value of non-physical assets like brand, history, and customer loyalty, which are often overlooked in simple financial analysis.
• Promotes a Long-Term View: The very nature of a sports franchise—with its multi-generational fan bases and decade-long media deals—is a powerful reminder that true investing is about owning a piece of a durable enterprise for years, not trading ticker symbols for days.

• Illiquidity and Limited Access: This is the most significant limitation. The vast majority of sports franchises are privately owned. You cannot simply go out and buy a piece of the Chicago Blackhawks. The model serves as an educational analogy, not a direct investment strategy.
• The “Trophy Asset” Problem: Unlike most CEOs, sports team owners are often motivated by ego, civic pride, and the thrill of winning, not purely by financial returns. This can lead to irrational decisions (like signing terrible, expensive player contracts) that would be unacceptable in a typical public company.
• Unique External Risks: The business is highly dependent on labor peace with players' unions. Lockouts or strikes can wipe out an entire season's worth of revenue. It is also susceptible to long-term shifts in cultural taste and concerns over player health and safety.

• economic_moat
• intrinsic_value
• margin_of_safety
• pricing_power
• intangible_assets
• capital_allocation
• circle_of_competence