InterPlanetary File System (IPFS)

• The Bottom Line: IPFS is a foundational new protocol for the internet that stores data based on what it is, not where it is, creating a more resilient, permanent, and decentralized web—a potential source of deep competitive moats for the businesses built upon it.
• Key Takeaways:
• What it is: A peer-to-peer network for storing and sharing files, where content is identified by a unique fingerprint (a “hash”) rather than a fragile web address (URL). Think of it as a global library where you ask for a book by its content, and anyone with a copy can provide it.
• Why it matters: It reduces dependence on centralized cloud providers like Amazon Web Services, potentially lowering long-term costs and eliminating single points of failure. This directly strengthens a company's operational resilience.
• How to use it: As a value investor, you analyze how a company leverages IPFS to build a durable competitive_advantage, enhance brand trust, or lower fundamental business risks—not to speculate on associated cryptocurrencies.

Imagine the current internet is like a giant, centralized library. To get a book (a piece of data, like a picture or an article), you must go to the librarian (a server) and ask for it by its specific shelf number (a URL, like `http://library.com/book.pdf`). This system works, but it has critical weaknesses:

• If the library burns down (the server crashes), the book is gone forever. We've all seen the “404 Not Found” error.
• If the librarian decides they don't like you, they can deny you access. This is censorship or de-platforming.
• If many people want the same popular book, they all have to queue up at the same library, causing congestion.
• If someone secretly replaces the book with a different one on the same shelf, you might not know you're getting fraudulent information.

IPFS reimagines this entire structure. Instead of a single, central library, imagine a global, interconnected network of millions of tiny personal libraries—a peer-to-peer system. In this new world, you don't ask for a book by its location. You ask for the book by its unique, unchanging content. Every piece of data on IPFS is put through a process that gives it a unique cryptographic fingerprint, called a Content Identifier (CID). This CID is derived directly from the content itself. If even one word in the book changes, the fingerprint changes completely. So, when you want the book, you broadcast to the entire network: “Hey, does anyone have the book with this exact fingerprint?” Anyone on the network who has a copy can send it to you. The a copy is then stored in your little library, and you can help share it with others. This seemingly simple shift from location-addressing (where is it?) to content-addressing (what is it?) has profound implications:

• Resilience: The “library” can't burn down. As long as at least one person on the network has a copy, the data is available.
• Permanence & Verifiability: Because the address (the CID) is the content's fingerprint, you can be 100% certain that the file you receive is the original, untampered version.
• Efficiency: For popular content, you can get it from a peer nearby instead of a distant server, making distribution faster and cheaper.

In essence, IPFS is a technological upgrade to the web's plumbing. It's not a company or a product you buy directly, but a foundational protocol, much like the HTTP that powers the web today.

“The key to investing is not assessing how much an industry is going to affect society, or how much it will grow, but rather determining the competitive advantage of any given company and, above all, the durability of that advantage.” - Warren Buffett
¹⁾

A value investor seeks durable, cash-producing businesses at reasonable prices. While a technology like IPFS might seem abstract, its potential impact on a company's fundamentals is very real. We are not interested in the hype; we are interested in how this tool can build a stronger, more profitable, and less risky business. Here's why IPFS should be on a value investor's radar:

• Building a Deeper, Digital Moat: A moat is what protects a company's profits from competitors. IPFS can help build several types of digital moats:
  • Switching Costs: If a company builds its platform around verifiable, permanent data (e.g., a supply chain tracking system for luxury goods), customers and partners become deeply integrated. Leaving for a competitor who can't offer the same level of trust becomes incredibly difficult.
  • Intangible Assets: A company can build immense brand trust by making its claims verifiable. Imagine an organic food company whose every certification is stored permanently on IPFS, linked via QR code on the packaging. This is a powerful form of brand equity that is difficult to fake.
  • Cost Advantages: For data-heavy businesses (like video streaming, scientific research, or archiving), distributing data via a peer-to-peer network can, at scale, be significantly cheaper than paying the recurring, toll-road fees of centralized providers like Amazon S3 or Google Cloud. These savings flow directly to the bottom line.
• Strengthening the Margin of Safety: The margin_of_safety is the buffer between a company's intrinsic value and its market price, but it also applies to a company's operational durability. A business's reliance on a single cloud provider is a significant, often overlooked, risk. What happens to a business built entirely on AWS if Amazon decides to raise prices by 30% or suffers a week-long outage?
  • By using a decentralized protocol like IPFS, a company diversifies its data infrastructure away from any single point of failure. This is a form of risk_management that makes the business fundamentally more robust and its future cash flows more predictable—the very essence of a safer investment.
• Distinguishing Substance from Hype: The world of Web3 and decentralization is flooded with speculation. The value investor's job is to ignore the noise and find the signal. Understanding IPFS allows you to ask the right questions. When a company claims it's “leveraging decentralized technology,” you can probe deeper: Are they simply “blockchain-washing” for a quick stock pop, or are they using IPFS to solve a real business problem that results in lower costs, higher revenue, or lower risk? This knowledge is a shield against speculative manias.

You don't “calculate” IPFS. You analyze its strategic implementation within a business. A savvy investor should approach a company's use of IPFS like a detective, looking for clues about its impact on the business's long-term value.

When a company you are analyzing mentions its use of IPFS or decentralized storage, use these questions to assess its materiality:

1. 1. What is the Core Problem Being Solved?
   • Is the company using IPFS to solve a mission-critical problem that was difficult or expensive to solve with traditional technology? (e.g., “We need to provide our users with a permanent, tamper-proof archive of legal documents.”)
   • Or is it a solution in search of a problem? (e.g., “We put our marketing website on IPFS to show we are innovative.”) The former points to genuine value creation; the latter is a potential red flag for marketing fluff.
2. 2. Does It Create a Measurable Economic Benefit?
   • Can management quantify the benefit? Look for metrics like:
     • “We reduced our data delivery costs by X%.”
     • “Our platform uptime increased to 99.999% due to decentralization, saving us an estimated $Y in lost revenue.”
     • “Our customer retention improved by Z% after we introduced verifiable data receipts.”
   • A lack of clear, measurable benefit suggests the implementation may not be significant to the company's intrinsic_value.
3. 3. How Is Data Persistence Ensured?
   • This is a crucial technical and economic question. Data on IPFS only persists as long as someone on the network is “pinning” (choosing to store) it. Ask:
     • Does the company run its own IPFS nodes to guarantee storage? (This incurs costs.)
     • Does it use a third-party pinning service? (This re-introduces some centralization.)
     • Does it leverage an incentive layer like filecoin to pay a distributed network of providers to store its data? (This creates a new line item in their expenses.)
   • Understanding the economic model behind data persistence is key to evaluating the long-term viability of the strategy.
4. 4. Is the Implementation Defensible?
   • How difficult would it be for a competitor to replicate this feature? If the value comes from a network effect (e.g., a huge, interconnected dataset of user-owned information), it can be a powerful moat. If it's a simple feature that any developer could add in a week, its value is minimal.

• A Strong Signal (Potential Value): The use of IPFS is deeply integrated into the core product, solves a real customer pain point, provides a clear and quantifiable economic benefit (lower costs, higher trust), and creates a durable competitive advantage that is hard to copy.
• A Weak Signal (Red Flag): The use of IPFS is mentioned in marketing materials but has no clear connection to the core business model. Management cannot articulate a specific economic benefit. The implementation feels superficial, designed to ride a technology trend rather than to build fundamental, long-term value.

Let's compare two fictional companies in the high-end art auction industry.

• “Legacy Auction House Inc.” operates on the traditional web.
• “Veritas Art Solutions” has built its platform on a decentralized stack, using IPFS.

^ Feature ^ Legacy Auction House Inc. (Traditional Web) ^ Veritas Art Solutions (IPFS-Powered) ^

In this example, Veritas isn't just a tech company; it's a fundamentally more trustworthy and resilient business. A value investor would recognize that its use of IPFS creates a powerful intangible asset (trust) and high switching costs for its clients, leading to more predictable long-term cash flows.

IPFS is a powerful tool, not a magic bullet. A clear-eyed investor must understand both its strengths and its weaknesses.

• Data Integrity: The content-addressing system provides a built-in, cryptographic guarantee that data has not been tampered with. This is invaluable for legal documents, scientific data, financial records, and NFTs.
• Enhanced Resilience: By eliminating single points of failure, IPFS offers a level of uptime and data durability that is difficult and expensive to achieve with centralized architectures.
• Censorship Resistance: Because data is hosted by many peers, it is very difficult for any single entity (a corporation or a government) to block or remove content from the network.
• Potential for Lower Costs: For distributing large, popular files, peer-to-peer delivery can significantly reduce bandwidth costs compared to a client-server model where one server must serve every request.

• The Permanence Double-Edged Sword: You cannot easily “delete” something from IPFS. Once a piece of data is on the network, it can be cached and re-shared by anyone. This creates significant challenges for personal privacy, the “right to be forgotten” (GDPR), and removing illegal content.
• The Persistence Problem: IPFS is not a free, magical hard drive in the sky. If no one on the network finds a piece of data valuable enough to “pin” (store), it will eventually disappear. A viable economic model (either self-hosting or paying for storage via services like filecoin) is essential and represents a real cost.
• Performance & Maturity: The IPFS network can sometimes be slower for retrieving content than a highly-optimized centralized server, especially for unpopular or obscure data. The technology is still evolving, and the developer toolchain is less mature than for the traditional web.
• The Lure of Speculation: The most significant pitfall for an investor is confusing the potential of the IPFS protocol with the speculative nature of related cryptocurrencies. Investing in a token is not the same as investing in a profitable business that uses the protocol to create value. Always focus on the business fundamentals.

• decentralization: The core principle of distributing power and infrastructure away from a central point of control.
• competitive_advantage: The ultimate goal of using a technology like IPFS—to build a defensible moat around a business.
• risk_management: How a business mitigates threats; IPFS can be a powerful tool for reducing operational and platform risk.
• blockchain: A related but distinct technology. Blockchains are often used for ordering transactions, while IPFS is used for off-chain storage of the associated data (e.g., an NFT's image).
• intangible_assets: Assets like brand reputation and trust, which IPFS can help strengthen through data verifiability.
• disruptive_technology: A technology that has the potential to fundamentally change how an industry operates, much like the internet itself did.
• margin_of_safety: The foundational principle of buying a great business with a buffer against unforeseen problems, including the technological risks that IPFS helps to mitigate.