Halving Cycle

• The Bottom Line: A pre-programmed event in cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin that reduces the rate of new supply, often fueling speculative frenzies that a true value investor should observe with caution, not participate in.
• Key Takeaways:
• What it is: A mechanism, written into the code of certain cryptocurrencies, that cuts the reward for “mining” new blocks in half, happening at regular intervals (roughly every four years for Bitcoin).
• Why it matters: It is a powerful driver of market narrative and speculation, offering a live case study in how an asset's price can become completely detached from any underlying intrinsic_value.
• How to use it: To understand the psychology of speculative bubbles and to reinforce the discipline of focusing on productive, cash-generating assets instead.

Imagine you own a magical goose that lays one golden egg every day. You, and everyone else, have built a market around these eggs. Now, imagine the goose comes with a rulebook, and the first rule states: “After every 1,000 eggs are laid, the goose will henceforth only lay one golden egg every TWO days.” The total supply of new eggs is suddenly, and permanently, cut in half. This is the essence of a halving cycle. It's a concept native to the world of cryptocurrencies, most famously Bitcoin. It's not a decision made by a CEO or a board of directors; it's a rule embedded in the computer code itself. In the case of Bitcoin, computers around the world (called “miners”) compete to solve complex math problems. The winner gets to validate a “block” of transactions and, as a reward, is given a certain amount of new bitcoin. The “halving” is a pre-scheduled event that cuts this reward in half.

• When Bitcoin started in 2009, the reward was 50 BTC per block.
• In 2012, the first halving occurred, and the reward dropped to 25 BTC.
• In 2016, it dropped to 12.5 BTC.
• In 2020, it dropped to 6.25 BTC.
• In 2024, it dropped to 3.125 BTC.

This process will continue until the maximum supply of 21 million bitcoins is reached. The core idea is to create digital scarcity, mimicking the finite supply of precious metals like gold. By automatically constricting the flow of new coins onto the market, the halving creates a “supply shock.” Proponents argue that if demand remains constant or increases, this supply reduction must lead to a higher price. This narrative is the fuel for the immense speculation that typically surrounds the event. For a value investor, however, this mechanism should be viewed through a lens of deep skepticism, as it has everything to do with price mechanics and nothing to do with value creation.

“An investment operation is one which, upon thorough analysis, promises safety of principal and an adequate return. Operations not meeting these requirements are speculative.”
– Benjamin Graham

To a value investor, the halving cycle matters not as an opportunity, but as a profound educational tool. It is perhaps the clearest modern illustration of the critical distinction between investment and speculation. An investor, in the tradition of Benjamin Graham and Warren Buffett, buys assets that produce things. You buy a share of a railroad because it generates cash by moving goods. You buy a piece of a software company because it generates profits by selling useful products. The value of your investment is tied to the underlying business's ability to generate more cash in the future. This is its intrinsic_value. The halving cycle operates in a completely different universe. It affects only one thing: the rate of new supply. It does not make the underlying cryptocurrency network more efficient, more useful, or more profitable. A bitcoin does not generate a single cent of earnings or cash flow. Its “value” is derived entirely from what the next person is willing to pay for it—the very essence of the greater_fool_theory. Here is why a value investor pays close attention to this phenomenon:

• A Masterclass in Market Psychology: The halving cycle is a perfect laboratory for studying Mr. Market in his most manic state. The event is known years in advance, yet the market consistently reacts with predictable cycles of hype, euphoria, and eventual disillusionment. Observing this helps an investor steel themselves against similar narrative-driven manias that can infect the stock market, from the dot-com bubble to other industry-specific crazes.
• It Highlights Narrative over Numbers: The story of “programmed scarcity” and “digital gold” is powerful and seductive. It's easy to understand and sounds futuristic. But a value investor's job is to ignore compelling narratives unless they are backed by cold, hard numbers: earnings, cash flows, and balance sheets. The halving cycle is 100% narrative and 0% fundamental business performance.
• Reinforces the Importance of a circle_of_competence: Warren Buffett famously avoids investments he doesn't understand. Can you, with certainty, project the cash flows of a cryptocurrency? No, because there are none. Can you determine its intrinsic value? No, for the same reason. The halving cycle's speculative nature is a stark reminder to stay within your circle of competence—the businesses you can analyze and value with a high degree of confidence.
• A Lesson in Price vs. Value: The price of a cryptocurrency might soar after a halving. But did its value change? A value investor would argue it did not, because the underlying asset's ability to produce cash (which is zero) remained unchanged. Price is what you pay; value is what you get. The halving cycle is a fascinating study in price, completely divorced from value.

In short, the halving cycle matters because it's a giant, flashing signpost that reads: “Warning: Speculation Ahead.” By understanding it, you can better appreciate the sanity and long-term security of sticking to the proven principles of value investing.

The goal for a value investor is not to “play” the halving cycle but to learn from it. You are the biologist observing the frenzy, not the participant caught within it.

1. Step 1: Acknowledge the Mechanics. Understand the simple supply-and-demand argument. Recognize that a reduction in new supply, if met with steady or rising demand, creates upward pressure on price. Acknowledge this without being seduced by it.
2. Step 2: Watch the Narrative Unfold. Pay attention to how financial media, social media personalities, and market pundits discuss the event. Notice the language used: “parabolic,” “supply shock,” “guaranteed returns.” These are hallmarks of speculation, not sober analysis.
3. Step 3: Contrast with Your Own Process. While the speculative world is fixated on the halving date, use that time to do the real work of an investor. Read the annual report of a company on your watchlist. Analyze its competitive advantages. Calculate its intrinsic value and see if it trades with a sufficient margin_of_safety. This contrast will highlight the difference between activity and productivity.
4. Step 4: Identify the Psychological Biases. Watch for Fear of Missing Out (FOMO), confirmation bias (people seeking out news that confirms their belief in higher prices), and herd mentality. Recognizing these biases in others makes you better equipped to recognize and suppress them in yourself.

A value investor can observe the typical psychological phases of a halving cycle to better understand how all speculative bubbles form and burst.

• The Pre-Halving Rally: Months before the event, anticipation builds. The narrative of the “supply shock” spreads, and speculators begin buying in the hope of front-running the expected price increase. This is driven purely by expectation.
• The “Sell the News” Event: Often, immediately following the halving, the price may stagnate or even fall. The reason is that the event was already “priced in” by the early speculators, who now sell to lock in profits. The reality fails to meet the hype.
• The Post-Halving Echo Bubble: Some time later, a new, broader wave of interest can emerge, often fueled by the initial price run-up attracting media attention and a new class of retail speculators. This phase is driven by price momentum and social proof, not fundamentals.
• The Inevitable Crash: Without an anchor of intrinsic value, speculative bubbles are fragile. Eventually, the buying hysteria exhausts itself, and the price collapses as everyone rushes for the exits at once.

For a value investor, this pattern is invaluable. You can see echoes of it in hyped-up IPOs, “meme stocks,” or any asset that becomes a popular story. By understanding the anatomy of the halving cycle bubble, you are vaccinated against catching the fever yourself.

To see the difference in mindset, let's compare two hypothetical assets an investor might consider.

The halving cycle is the engine of the SpeculoCoin “investment” thesis. It encourages a focus on second-guessing the crowd and timing the market—two activities a value investor actively avoids. The value investor, meanwhile, is focused on the boring but profitable business of Steady Savers Bank. They don't care about narratives; they care about the tangible book value, the earnings power, and whether they can buy a dollar's worth of assets for sixty cents. The halving cycle is, to them, irrelevant noise.

• A Powerful Psychological Mirror: The halving cycle is an unparalleled case study in market psychology. It shows, in a recurring and predictable way, how greed, FOMO, and narrative can drive prices to irrational extremes.
• Reinforces Investment Discipline: By observing the speculative frenzy from a safe distance, a value investor's commitment to fundamental analysis, patience, and a long-term mindset is strengthened. It's a reminder of what not to do.
• Clarifies the Definition of an “Asset”: It forces a clear distinction between a speculative vehicle (like a cryptocurrency) and a true, productive asset that generates cash flow (like a business, a farm, or a rental property).

• The Seduction of a Simple Narrative: The biggest danger is believing the hype. The story that “less supply must mean higher price” is simple and compelling. It can lure investors away from the difficult but necessary work of analyzing businesses.
• Mistaking Price for Value: The halving cycle is all about price movement. Investors caught in its thrall can easily forget to ask the most important question: “What is this thing actually worth?” Without an anchor in intrinsic value, any price is possible, both on the way up and on the way down.
• Promotes a Trader's Mindset: The entire event encourages short-term thinking, market timing, and trying to outsmart other market participants. This is the antithesis of the value investor's mindset, which is to think like a long-term business owner.

• speculation_vs_investment
• intrinsic_value
• mr_market
• margin_of_safety
• circle_of_competence
• market_sentiment
• greater_fool_theory