Co-investment

• The Bottom Line: Co-investment is your opportunity to invest directly into a specific private company alongside a professional lead investor, such as a private equity firm, often with significantly lower fees and a front-row seat to their expert analysis.
• Key Takeaways:
• What it is: Instead of putting money into a “blind pool” fund that invests in many companies, you are choosing to invest in a single, specific deal that the fund's manager has sourced and vetted.
• Why it matters: It provides access to potentially undervalued private companies you couldn't otherwise own, while leveraging the deep due_diligence of a professional team and better aligning your interests with theirs.
• How to use it: For eligible investors, it's a tool for building a more concentrated, high-conviction portfolio of private assets, but it demands careful evaluation of both the lead investor and the individual deal itself.

Imagine a highly respected, seasoned real estate developer, let's call her “ProInvest,” who has an incredible track record of finding undervalued apartment buildings, fixing them up, and selling them for a handsome profit years later. Typically, you might invest with ProInvest by putting your money into her “ProInvest Real Estate Fund.” You give her your capital, and she and her team go out and buy a dozen different buildings over the next few years. You trust her judgment, but you have no say in which specific buildings she buys. You are a passive, “limited partner” in a blind pool. Now, imagine ProInvest finds an absolute gem: a well-built, 50-unit apartment building in a growing neighborhood, currently mismanaged and underpriced. It's a bigger project than usual, and she needs extra capital to close the deal. Instead of just using her fund's money, she calls a few of her most trusted investors, including you. She says, “I'm buying the Elm Street Apartments for $10 million. My firm is putting in $4 million, and our fund is putting in $3 million. I have an opportunity for you to come in alongside us and invest the final $3 million directly into this single property, on the exact same terms as us.” That is co-investment. You are not just giving money to a fund; you are making a conscious decision to invest in a specific asset (the Elm Street Apartments) alongside an expert sponsor (ProInvest) who also has significant skin_in_the_game. You get to see the address, review the financials, and understand the specific business plan for that building before you commit a single dollar. It's a more focused, transparent, and direct way to partner with expert investors.

“It's far better to buy a wonderful company at a fair price than a fair company at a wonderful price.” - Warren Buffett
¹⁾

For a disciplined value investor, co-investment isn't just another financial product; it's a structure that resonates deeply with the core principles of Benjamin Graham and Warren Buffett. It's an opportunity to apply a value mindset to the world of private markets.

• Leveraging World-Class Due Diligence: A true value investor's work begins with rigorous, painstaking research. A top-tier private equity (PE) firm might spend thousands of hours and millions of dollars on legal, financial, and operational due diligence before buying a single company. As a co-investor, you become a direct beneficiary of this institutional-grade research. While you must always do your own homework, you are starting with a foundation of analysis far beyond what an individual could replicate. It's like having a world-class investigative team hand you a deeply researched dossier before you make a decision.
• True Alignment of Interests: Value investors are wary of situations where incentives are misaligned. In a traditional fund, a manager might be tempted to grow assets to earn higher management fees, even on mediocre deals. In a co-investment, the lead sponsor is investing their own capital—and often their fund's capital—right alongside yours, on the same terms. This powerful alignment, often called “eating your own cooking,” ensures they are laser-focused on the success of that one specific company. Their success is directly and immediately tied to your success, which significantly reduces the principal_agent_problem.
• A Structural margin_of_safety: The most significant advantage is often economic. Co-investments typically come with much lower fees than a traditional fund investment. A standard PE fund might charge a “2 and 20” fee structure (a 2% annual management fee on assets and 20% of the profits). Co-investments, offered as an incentive to key investors, often have a “0 and 10” or “1 and 15” structure, or sometimes no fees at all. This fee reduction is a direct boost to your net return. It acts as a structural “margin of safety” for your investment; the underlying company doesn't have to perform as spectacularly for you to achieve a good outcome.
• Focus on intrinsic_value and Long-Term Operations: Co-investing is the antithesis of short-term market speculation. You are partnering with a sponsor whose entire thesis is based on buying a business for less than its long-term worth and then actively working to increase that intrinsic value over a 5-10 year period through operational improvements, strategic guidance, and better management. This long-term, business-owner mindset is the very essence of value investing.

Co-investment is not a strategy you can execute through a standard brokerage account. It exists in the private markets and requires a different approach.

Applying the co-investment strategy is a multi-step process focused on access, evaluation, and careful selection.

1. 1. Becoming an Eligible Investor: Co-investment opportunities are almost exclusively available to accredited investors or qualified purchasers. ²⁾ This is the first gate you must pass.
2. 2. Finding and Vetting a Lead Sponsor: You don't find co-investments; you find the people who offer them. The most critical decision is choosing the right lead investor (the General Partner or “GP”). A value investor would analyze the GP like they would any business:
   • Track Record: Have they consistently generated strong returns across market cycles?
   • Expertise: Do they have deep, demonstrable operational experience in a specific industry (e.g., healthcare, software, industrial manufacturing)? Avoid generalists.
   • Discipline: Do they stick to their valuation principles, or do they chase hot deals? Are they willing to walk away if the price isn't right?
   • Transparency: How do they communicate with their investors, especially when things go wrong?
3. 3. Conducting Your Own Due Diligence: The GP's research is your starting point, not your conclusion. A value investor never subcontracts their thinking. You must pressure-test the sponsor's investment thesis. This involves:
   • Reading the entire investment memorandum and financial model.
   • Asking tough questions: What are the biggest risks? What assumptions in the model are most fragile? How, specifically, will you increase the company's value?
   • Independently researching the company's industry, competitive position, and management team.
4. 4. Understanding the Deal Structure & Exit: This is a long-term, illiquid investment. You must be comfortable locking up your capital for 5-10 years, or sometimes longer. Scrutinize the legal documents to understand governance rights, how decisions are made, and what the likely path to an exit is (e.g., sale to a larger company, an IPO).

Here is a framework a value investor might use when presented with a co-investment deal.

Let's consider Sarah, an accredited investor who has invested in a private equity fund run by “Bedrock Capital Partners,” a firm known for its value-oriented approach to buying stable, family-owned industrial businesses. Bedrock's fund identifies a target: “Legacy Gears Inc.,” a 40-year-old manufacturer of specialty gears for heavy machinery. Legacy has a great reputation and sticky customer relationships but has been slow to modernize its operations and has no succession plan for its retiring founder. Bedrock negotiates to buy Legacy for $50 million, a price they believe is 30% below its intrinsic value. Their plan is to invest in new CNC machinery to improve efficiency and hire a new CEO with industry experience to expand the sales team. The deal requires $20 million in equity. Bedrock's fund commits $15 million, but they offer the remaining $5 million as a co-investment opportunity to their key investors, including Sarah. The co-investment has zero management fees and 10% carry, far better than the fund's standard 2% and 20%. Sarah doesn't just say yes. She applies her value investing checklist: 1. The Business: She sees that Legacy Gears has a durable moat built on reputation and engineering know-how. Its customers are unlikely to switch suppliers over small price differences. It's a “boring,” predictable business—which she loves. 2. The Sponsor's Thesis: Bedrock's plan isn't based on financial magic. It's a concrete, operational plan to improve a good-but-stagnant company. This makes sense to her. 3. The Valuation: She reviews Bedrock's financial model. She sees they are buying the company for 6x its annual cash flow, while similar public companies trade at 9x. This provides a clear margin of safety from day one. 4. The Terms: The fee-light structure is highly attractive. She also sees that Bedrock's partners are personally investing $2 million of their own money into the deal, demonstrating huge skin_in_the_game. After her analysis, Sarah decides to co-invest $500,000 directly into Legacy Gears. She understands her money is tied up for the long term, but she is confident she is partnering with a smart operator to buy a good business at a fair price.

• Superior Economics: The single biggest advantage is the potential for significantly lower fees. Over the life of an investment, a reduction from a “2 and 20” to a “0 and 10” structure can add several percentage points to your annualized return.
• Enhanced Selectivity: Unlike a blind pool fund, co-investing allows you to say “no.” You can curate a portfolio of private companies you specifically understand and believe in, aligning your capital with your highest-conviction ideas.
• Accelerated Learning: Evaluating individual deals alongside top professionals is an incredible education in business analysis, valuation, and deal structuring. You gain direct insight into how experts think.
• Deeper Alignment: By investing in a specific deal, you are more closely aligned with the GP than in a large, diversified fund. Everyone's focus is on making that one company a success.

• Concentration Risk: By definition, you are concentrating your capital into a single company. If that company fails, your entire investment could be lost. It lacks the diversification of a traditional fund.
• Requires Significant Expertise: You cannot blindly trust the sponsor. Co-investing is only suitable for investors who have the financial literacy and business acumen to conduct their own thorough due diligence on a specific company and industry.
• Adverse Selection Risk: You must always ask: Why am I being offered this deal? Are the best deals kept entirely within the fund? Sometimes, GPs offer co-investments for deals that are larger or riskier than their fund's mandate allows. ³⁾
• Extreme Illiquidity: There is no public market for your shares. Your capital is locked up until the sponsor decides to sell the company, a process that can take a decade or more. You have virtually no control over the timing of your exit.

• private_equity
• due_diligence
• margin_of_safety
• intrinsic_value
• illiquidity
• accredited_investor
• skin_in_the_game
• principal_agent_problem