This is an old revision of the document!
S&P Global Ratings
S&P Global Ratings is one of the world's most influential credit rating agencies, a division of the financial information giant S&P Global. Think of them as a financial watchdog, but instead of barking at intruders, they issue grades on the creditworthiness of companies, cities, and even entire countries. Along with its main rivals, Moody's Investors Service and Fitch Ratings, it forms what is known as the “Big Three” in the credit rating world. An S&P rating is essentially a forward-looking opinion on a borrower's ability to pay back its debt on time and in full. For investors, these ratings are a crucial first stop. A high rating can signal a financially sound company, while a low rating flashes a warning sign about potential risk. This simple letter grade, from AAA to D, can influence the interest rate a company pays on its bonds, the price of its stock, and whether certain large funds are even allowed to invest in it. It’s a powerful shortcut for assessing financial risk, but as we'll see, it's a tool that should be handled with care.
How Do S&P Ratings Work?
S&P uses a simple-to-understand letter-grade system to communicate its opinion. This system is split into two main categories, with plus (+) or minus (-) signs used to show finer distinctions within a grade (e.g., AA+ is better than AA, which is better than AA-).
The Rating Scale
The scale runs from the gold-standard 'AAA' down to 'D' for a borrower already in default. The most important dividing line for investors is between investment grade and speculative grade.
- Investment Grade (Rated BBB- or higher): These are considered the safest bets. Companies and governments with these ratings have a strong capacity to meet their financial obligations. Think of corporate titans with fortress-like balance sheets.
- Speculative Grade (Rated BB+ or lower): Often called 'junk bonds', these carry a higher risk of default. To compensate investors for taking on this extra risk, these bonds typically offer higher interest payments (yields). These are issued by companies that might be younger, in a tougher industry, or carrying more debt.
Rating Outlooks
S&P doesn't just assign a static grade; it also provides an “outlook.” This tells you which way the wind might be blowing for the rating over the next six months to two years.
- Positive: The rating may be raised.
- Negative: The rating may be lowered.
- Stable: The rating is unlikely to change.
- Developing: The rating could go either way, often pending a major event like a merger.
A Value Investor's Perspective on Credit Ratings
For a value investor, a credit rating is a useful piece of information, but it should never be the only piece of information. It's a starting point for investigation, not a substitute for it.
A Useful Starting Point, Not a Final Verdict
A consistently high credit rating (e.g., A or better) is often a sign of a high-quality business. It usually indicates stable earnings, strong cash flow, and a defensible market position—what Warren Buffett would call a strong competitive moat. For an investor screening for robust, durable companies, a strong credit rating can be a helpful filter. It quickly tells you that, in S&P's opinion, the company is not in immediate financial danger and can comfortably manage its debts.
The Perils of Over-Reliance
History provides a stark warning against blindly trusting credit ratings. During the lead-up to the 2008 financial crisis, rating agencies, including S&P, gave their highest AAA ratings to complex mortgage-backed securities (like collateralized debt obligations or CDOs) that were packed with risky loans. When the housing market buckled, these “super-safe” investments imploded, triggering a global meltdown. This episode highlighted two major issues:
- Conflict of Interest: The agencies are paid by the very companies whose debt they are rating. This “issuer-pays” model creates a potential conflict of interest, where an agency might be tempted to give a favorable rating to keep a large client happy.
- They Can Be Wrong: At the end of the day, a rating is an opinion based on models and human judgment, both of which can be flawed. The agencies missed the systemic risk brewing in the housing market.
This is why the core principle of value investing—doing your own due diligence—is paramount. You cannot outsource your thinking. You must read the financial statements, understand the business, and form your own conclusion about its financial health and long-term prospects.
Conclusion: Use, Don't Abuse
S&P Global Ratings provides a valuable service. Its ratings offer a quick and standardized way to gauge the credit risk of a bond or a company. Use them as a first-glance tool to understand how the market views a company's financial stability. However, never let a rating be your final word. A truly wise investor digs deeper, questioning the assumptions behind the rating and focusing on the underlying business's true intrinsic value. A credit rating is a single chapter in a company's story; it's your job to read the whole book.