Finding and Development Costs (F&D) [CapiPedia]

This page is read only. You can view the source, but not change it. Ask your administrator if you think this is wrong.
====== Finding and Development Costs (F&D) ======
Finding and Development Costs (F&D) are the total expenses an oil and gas company incurs to add new energy reserves to its portfolio. Think of it as the all-in price tag for discovering a new underground stash of oil or natural gas and getting it ready for extraction. This isn't just the cost of drilling a successful well; it includes every penny spent on the hunt. This means paying for geological surveys, leasing mineral rights, drilling both successful and unsuccessful exploratory wells (//dry holes//), and building the initial infrastructure needed to access the reserves. For a value investor analyzing an energy company, F&D cost isn't just an accounting line item; it's a direct measure of the company's skill. A company that can consistently find and develop energy for a low cost has a powerful and sustainable competitive advantage, much like a retailer who can acquire prime store locations for less than its rivals.
===== Why F&D Costs Matter to a Value Investor =====
For an oil and gas company, its reserves are its lifeblood. Just like a factory depreciates, an oil well depletes over time. To survive and thrive, the company must constantly replace the oil and gas it pumps out of the ground. F&D costs tell you how efficiently it's doing this.
The key metric here is the **F&D cost per barrel of oil equivalent ([[BOE]])**. This single number tells you how much capital the company had to spend to add one barrel of new reserves. A low and stable F&D cost per BOE is a hallmark of a well-run operation. It suggests the management team has superior geological expertise, better technology, or a shrewder land-acquisition strategy than its competitors. Conversely, a rapidly rising F&D cost is a major red flag. It can indicate that the company is running out of easy-to-find resources and is now spending more and more money just to stand still, a sure-fire way to destroy shareholder value over the long term.
===== Putting F&D Costs into Practice =====
Looking at F&D costs isn't just an academic exercise. It's a practical tool for sizing up an energy investment. Here’s how to use it.
==== Calculating F&D Costs per Barrel ====
The basic formula is straightforward, though it requires a bit of digging in a company's annual report.
**F&D Cost per BOE = Total [[Exploration and Development Costs]] / Total New [[Proved Reserves]] Added (in BOE)**
  * **Exploration and Development Costs:** This is the total money spent on finding and developing new reserves, often referred to as [[Capital Expenditures]] (CapEx) in the "Investing Activities" section of the cash flow statement. You are looking for the costs associated with exploration and development, sometimes called "E&D."
  * **New Proved Reserves Added:** This figure is found in the supplementary information of the annual report, usually in a table detailing changes in the company's proved reserves over the year.
**Important:** Because large discoveries are lumpy and don't happen on a neat annual schedule, it's crucial to use a multi-year average (typically 3 to 5 years) for both the costs and the added reserves. This smooths out the volatility and gives you a much more reliable picture of the company's true replacement efficiency.
==== What's a 'Good' F&D Cost? ====
A "good" F&D number is always relative. An F&D cost of $15 per barrel might be excellent for a deep-water project in the Gulf of Mexico but terrible for an onshore shale gas well in Texas. The key is to compare a company's F&D cost against its direct peers operating in the same geographical and geological areas.
To take your analysis to the next level, you can calculate the **[[Recycle Ratio]]**. This powerful metric shows how many times the company can earn back its F&D cost from the profit generated by a barrel of oil.
**Recycle Ratio = [[Netback]] per BOE / F&D Cost per BOE**
The //Netback// is the operating profit margin per barrel after subtracting all the costs of lifting the oil out of the ground (production costs, taxes, and royalties). A Recycle Ratio of 2.0x means that for every $1 the company spends finding a barrel of oil, it expects to generate $2 of pre-tax profit from that barrel over its lifetime. The higher the Recycle Ratio, the more profitable the company's growth engine is. A ratio consistently above 2.0x is generally considered healthy.
===== The Value Investor's Checklist =====
When analyzing the F&D costs of an oil and gas company, keep these points in mind:
  * **Look for a low and stable trend.** Is the 3-year average F&D cost per BOE consistently low compared to peers and stable or declining over time?
  * **Compare against the competition.** A company's F&D cost is only meaningful when benchmarked against its direct competitors.
  * **Calculate the Recycle Ratio.** This is the true test of profitability. A company might have low F&D costs, but if its production costs are high (resulting in a low Netback), the investment may still be unattractive.
  * **Beware of rising costs.** A company whose F&D costs are relentlessly climbing is likely facing operational challenges or depleting its best assets. This is a warning sign that future returns may be under pressure.