Exchange-Traded Currencies (ETCs)

• The Bottom Line: Exchange-Traded Currencies (ETCs) are stock market-traded IOUs from a bank that track a currency's value, but for a value investor, they are primarily speculative tools with significant, often misunderstood, risks.
• Key Takeaways:
• What it is: An ETC is a debt security, issued by a financial institution, that trades on a stock exchange like a stock, with its price designed to mirror the performance of a specific currency or currency pair.
• Why it matters: Unlike an ETF which holds underlying assets, an ETC represents a promise to pay from the issuer. This introduces counterparty_risk—the risk that the issuing bank could fail, potentially rendering your investment worthless.
• How to use it: While primarily used for speculation, the only prudent application for a value investor is as a sophisticated hedging tool to protect the value of existing international investments from adverse currency swings.

Imagine you want to bet on the Swiss Franc strengthening against the US Dollar. In the old days, you’d have to open a complicated forex trading account or physically buy francs and store them. Today, you can simply buy an ETC in your regular brokerage account, just like you’d buy shares of Apple or Ford. But here’s the critical part that most people miss: you are not buying the currency itself. Think of an ETC as a “Chameleon IOU”. You give your money to a big bank (the issuer, like a Barclays or a Deutsche Bank). In return, they give you an IOU—a type of bond or note. This isn't a normal IOU with a fixed value, though. It’s a chameleon. Its value is designed to change color, moment by moment, to perfectly match the value of the currency it’s tracking. If the Swiss Franc goes up 1% against the dollar, the value of your Chameleon IOU also goes up 1%. It's convenient, it's liquid, and it trades all day on the stock exchange. This sounds a lot like an Exchange-Traded Fund (ETF), but there's a fundamental, night-and-day difference. A Swiss Franc ETF would likely hold actual Swiss Francs in a vault somewhere. It owns the asset. The Swiss Franc ETC, on the other hand, holds nothing but a promise from its issuer. It is an unsecured debt obligation. You are not an owner of an asset; you are a lender to a bank. This distinction is the single most important thing to understand about ETCs, and it's the source of their greatest risk. Currencies, much like gold, are what Warren Buffett would call non-productive assets. They don't generate earnings, pay dividends, or produce anything. An investment in a currency is a bet on its future price relative to another currency, which is fundamentally a speculative activity.

“Gold gets dug out of the ground in Africa, or someplace. Then we melt it down, dig another hole, bury it again and pay people to stand around guarding it. It has no utility. Anyone watching from Mars would be scratching their head.” - Warren Buffett ¹⁾

For a value investor, the concept of an ETC should trigger more alarm bells than a fire drill in a fireworks factory. The entire value investing philosophy is built on principles that ETCs, when used for speculation, directly contradict. 1. Speculation vs. Investment: Benjamin Graham, the father of value investing, drew a bright line between investing and speculating. An investment operation is one which, upon thorough analysis, promises safety of principal and an adequate return. Operations not meeting these requirements are speculative. Buying a currency ETC because you have a “hunch” the Euro is going to rise is pure speculation. Currencies have no intrinsic value in the traditional sense. They don't have earnings, cash flows, or a book value to analyze. Their value is determined by complex macroeconomic forces, government policies, and the whims of global traders. You're not buying a piece of a productive business; you're betting on a number on a screen. 2. The Hidden Threat of Counterparty Risk: This is the deal-breaker. A core tenet of value investing is the Margin of Safety. You build in a buffer to protect your principal from errors in judgment or bad luck. An ETC's structure fundamentally violates this principle in a hidden way. Because it's a debt note, its value depends on two things: the currency movement and the financial health of the issuer. If the issuing bank goes bankrupt (think Lehman Brothers in 2008), the “IOU” they gave you could become worthless, regardless of what the currency did. You could be 100% right on your currency bet and still lose 100% of your money. This is an uncompensated risk that many investors don't even know they are taking. 3. The Circle of Competence: Warren Buffett famously advises investors to stay within their circle_of_competence. Do you have a deep, enduring, and provable edge in predicting global interest rate policies, trade balances, and geopolitical events? If the answer is no, then currency trading is not a game you should be playing. You are competing against central banks, multinational corporations, and hedge funds with billions of dollars and armies of PhDs dedicated to this full-time. It's a game heavily stacked against the individual investor. So, are ETCs completely useless? Not quite. For the sophisticated value investor with significant international holdings, they can serve one narrow, defensive purpose: hedging. This is not about making a profit, but about protecting the value of an existing, productive investment from currency fluctuations.

We must separate the application of ETCs into two distinct paths: the speculator's path, which a value investor should avoid, and the hedger's path, which can be a legitimate, albeit advanced, strategy.

Approach 1: The Speculator's Path (The Pitfall to Avoid) This is the most common use of ETCs and the one we advise against.

1. Step 1: You read a news headline or hear a TV pundit claim that the Japanese Yen is “poised to fall” due to a policy change at the Bank of Japan.
2. Step 2: You log into your brokerage account and buy an ETC that is designed to go up when the Yen falls against the US Dollar.
3. Step 3: You cross your fingers and hope your prediction is right.

This is not investing. You have no margin of safety. Your “analysis” is based on hearsay, and you are betting against the world's most sophisticated market participants. This is a ticket to the poorhouse. Approach 2: The Value Investor's Path (A Defensive Hedge) This is a risk-management strategy, not a profit-seeking one.

1. Step 1: Identify a Concentrated Foreign Asset Exposure. You have done your homework and, after careful analysis, you've invested a significant portion of your portfolio in a wonderful German manufacturing company. Your shares are denominated in Euros (€).
2. Step 2: Quantify the Currency Risk. Let's say your investment is worth €200,000. At an exchange rate of 1.10 USD/EUR, your stake is worth $220,000. You believe in the company long-term, but you are concerned that the Euro might weaken against the Dollar over the next year, which would reduce the value of your investment in your home currency (USD). If the Euro fell to 1.00 USD/EUR, your investment would only be worth $200,000—a loss of $20,000 due to currency alone.
3. Step 3: Implement a Protective Hedge. To neutralize this risk, you could purchase an ETC that is designed to go up in value as the Euro falls. You would buy an amount of the ETC roughly equivalent to your exposure. For instance, you might buy $220,000 worth of an “Inverse Euro” ETC.
4. Step 4: Analyze the Outcome. Now, if the Euro falls as you feared, the value of your German stock in USD will decrease. However, the value of your Inverse Euro ETC will rise by a similar amount. The gain on the ETC helps offset the currency loss on your stock, preserving the value of your principal in US Dollars. You have successfully isolated your investment's performance from currency fluctuations. ²⁾

When using an ETC for hedging, the “ideal” result is that the ETC doesn't make you a huge profit. If your hedge performs perfectly, its gains or losses will simply be the mirror image of the currency's effect on your primary investment. The goal is not to make money on the ETC; the goal is to remove currency volatility from your investment thesis, allowing you to focus on the underlying business performance of the company you own. A large gain on your hedging ETC likely means your primary international asset has taken a large currency-related hit, and vice-versa. Success is a flat line—a neutralization of risk.

Let's illustrate the difference between speculation and hedging with two investors, “Gambling Gary” and “Prudent Penelope.”

This example clearly shows that for a value investor, the purpose of an ETC is to act as insurance, not as a lottery ticket.

• Accessibility and Convenience: ETCs allow any investor with a standard brokerage account to gain exposure to currency markets without needing a specialized forex account.
• Liquidity: Most ETCs tied to major currencies are traded on large exchanges, making them easy to buy and sell throughout the trading day.
• Transparency: The pricing of the ETC is directly tied to the underlying currency exchange rates, which are publicly available in real-time.

• Counterparty Risk: This is the most significant and often-ignored weakness. You are lending money to a bank. If that bank fails, your investment can be wiped out, regardless of the currency's performance. This is not a theoretical risk; the 2008 financial crisis showed that even the largest institutions can fail.
• Fundamentally Speculative: For 99% of use cases, ETCs encourage speculation on non-productive assets, which is the antithesis of value investing. They lure investors into a game where they have a significant disadvantage.
• Confusion with ETFs: Many investors incorrectly assume ETCs are a type of ETF and hold underlying assets, giving them a false sense of security. They are debt instruments, and this crucial difference must be understood.
• Costs and Fees: ETCs charge annual expense ratios, just like ETFs. These fees, while often small, create a constant drag on performance. For a long-term hedge, these costs can add up.
• Tracking Error: While usually minor for major currencies, an ETC may not perfectly track the currency's movement due to fees, the structure of the underlying derivatives, or market disruptions.

• exchange_traded_fund_etf
• counterparty_risk
• margin_of_safety
• speculation
• circle_of_competence
• hedging
• risk_management