13F Report

• The Bottom Line: A 13F report is a treasure map to the recent stock purchases of Wall Street's biggest investors, but it's a map of where they were, not where they are going.
• Key Takeaways:
• What it is: A mandatory quarterly filing with the SEC that reveals the U.S. stock holdings of institutional investors managing over $100 million.
• Why it matters: It's a powerful tool for generating investment ideas by peeking into the portfolios of legendary value investors like Warren Buffett.
• How to use it: Not for blind copying, but as a starting point for your own rigorous due_diligence to see if their ideas make sense for your portfolio.

Imagine you're an aspiring chef. What if you could get a copy of Gordon Ramsay's or Julia Child's grocery list from last month? You wouldn't know the exact recipes they were planning, and you'd know they've already bought and probably used those ingredients. Still, that list would be an incredible source of inspiration. You'd see they were buying high-quality seasonal vegetables, a specific cut of beef, and an exotic spice you've never heard of. It would give you fantastic ideas for your own cooking. A 13F report is the investing world's equivalent of that master chef's shopping list. Legally speaking, it's a quarterly report required by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Any institutional investment manager with at least $100 million in qualifying assets under management ¹⁾ must file it. This report is due within 45 days after the end of each calendar quarter (March, June, September, December). In plain English, it's a public declaration where big-time money managers—like Berkshire Hathaway (Warren Buffett's firm), Pershing Square (Bill Ackman), or Scion Asset Management (Michael Burry)—have to show the world most of their U.S. stock positions. The report lists the company, the number of shares they own, and the total market value of that holding at the end of the quarter. It's a delayed, partial glimpse into the minds of some of the world's best capital allocators. It shows you the “what” (what they bought or sold), but it never tells you the crucial “why.”

“You can't produce a baby in one month by getting nine women pregnant. It just doesn't work that way. There's a gestation period for everything, including investments.” - Warren Buffett. This quote serves as a perfect reminder that seeing a great investor buy a stock is only the beginning of the process, not the end.

For a value investor, a 13F filing is not a “hot tip” sheet. To treat it as such is to engage in speculation, the very thing we seek to avoid. Instead, it is a powerful tool for disciplined, intelligent investing when used correctly. Here's why it's so valuable:

• Idea Generation: The world of publicly traded companies is vast. It's impossible to analyze every single one. 13F filings act as a high-quality filter. When a successful value investor—someone you know is disciplined, patient, and focused on intrinsic value—makes a significant new investment, it's a signal. It tells you, “Hey, a smart person who does this for a living thinks there might be something special here.” This is an invitation to start your research, not to end it.
• A Gauge of Conviction: A 13F doesn't just show what investors own; it shows how much. If a manager you respect opens a new position that represents 10% of their reported portfolio, that signals immense conviction. Conversely, if it's a tiny 0.5% position, it might be a small “starter” position they are still researching. This helps you understand the intensity of their belief in an idea.
• Behavioral Fortitude: Investing can be a lonely game. When you've done your homework on a company that the market hates, and you believe it's trading far below its true worth, it can be unnerving. Seeing a respected value investor's 13F report show they were also buying that same unloved stock can provide a valuable psychological boost. It's not a substitute for your own analysis, but it can be a comforting confirmation that another rational mind sees what you see.
• Learning Tool: By tracking the filings of great investors over time, you can learn how they navigate different market cycles. You can see how they apply their stated philosophy in the real world. Do they buy more during market panics? Do they trim positions when stocks become overvalued? Studying 13Fs is like having a silent mentor, showing you the principles of value investing in action. It helps you stay focused on the long-term and reinforces the importance of principles like margin_of_safety.

Using a 13F filing effectively is a process of disciplined investigation, not impulsive action. Here is a step-by-step method a value investor should follow.

1. Step 1: Curate Your “Superinvestors”. Don't follow everyone. Identify a handful of investment managers whose philosophy deeply resonates with your own. Are you a deep value, Ben Graham-style investor? Or do you prefer Warren Buffett's “wonderful companies at fair prices” approach? Create a short, high-quality list. Following too many will just create noise.
2. Step 2: Access the Filings. You can go directly to the SEC's EDGAR database, but this can be clunky. Several excellent free websites aggregate this data and present it in a much more user-friendly format (e.g., Dataroma, WhaleWisdom). These sites often show a manager's portfolio history, new buys, and recent sales all on one page.
3. Step 3: Focus on the Changes. Don't just look at a snapshot of the current portfolio. The most valuable information lies in the changes from the previous quarter.
   • New Buys: These are often the best source of fresh ideas.
   • Increased Positions: This shows growing conviction in an existing idea.
   • Sold Out Positions: This could indicate the investment thesis played out, the stock became overvalued, or the investor made a mistake.
   • Decreased Positions: This might be prudent profit-taking or a sign of wavering conviction.
4. Step 4: Ask Critical Questions. Once you spot an interesting move (e.g., a big new buy), your work begins. Ask yourself:
   • Does this company fit within the investor's known circle_of_competence?
   • Why might they find this attractive now? Has the stock price fallen recently? Is there a new catalyst?
   • What is the company's business model? Does it have a durable competitive advantage, or a “moat”?
   • Is this a large, high-conviction bet or just a small nibble?
5. Step 5: Conduct Your Own Independent Due Diligence. This is the most important step. The 13F is the question, not the answer. You must now build your own investment_thesis. Read the company's annual reports (10-Ks), listen to earnings calls, analyze the financials, and calculate your own estimate of its intrinsic value. Only if—and only if—the current stock price offers a significant margin_of_safety below your calculated value should you even consider investing.

Let's imagine it's August 14th, and the Q2 13F filings (for the quarter ending June 30th) have just been released. You follow a respected, no-nonsense value investor named Eleanor Vance of “Vance Capital Management.” You pull up her latest 13F and compare it to her Q1 filing.

You immediately notice the big, bold new position: Reliable Railroad Co. (RRC).

• The Speculator's Path (The Wrong Way): A speculator sees this and thinks, “Eleanor Vance is a genius! RRC must be a great buy!” He immediately logs into his brokerage account and buys shares of RRC without any further research. He is blindly following, outsourcing his thinking, and taking on unknown risks.
• The Value Investor's Path (The Right Way): You, the prudent value investor, see this as a fascinating lead. You begin the process outlined above:
  • Question: “Why a railroad? They are capital intensive but have huge moats. The stock has dropped 20% in the last four months due to recession fears. Eleanor is likely taking advantage of that pessimism.”
  • Research: You spend the next two weeks reading everything you can about RRC. You study its route network (its moat), its pricing power, its management's track record on capital allocation, and its historical return on capital.
  • Valuation: You build a discounted cash flow model and determine that your conservative estimate of RRC's intrinsic value is $150 per share.
  • Action: You check the current stock price. It's trading at $105. This represents a 30% discount to your calculated value, which is a sufficient margin_of_safety. Because you've done your own homework and agree with the likely thesis, you decide to initiate a position.

The speculator bought a stock ticker. You invested in a business you understand, at a price you calculated to be attractive. That is the profound difference in using a 13F report correctly.

• High-Quality Idea Funnel: It narrows the investment universe down to ideas that have already been vetted by some of the most successful investors in the world.
• Transparency: It provides a rare, albeit delayed, window into the actions of managers who are otherwise very private about their specific trades.
• Behavioral Insight: It helps you understand how great investors behave during different market conditions, reinforcing good long-term habits.
• Free of Charge: This incredibly valuable data is available for free to any investor willing to look for it.

• The Time Lag: This is the single biggest weakness. The data is, at best, 45 days old and could be up to 135 days old. The manager might have already sold the position you see as a “new buy.” You are always looking in the rearview mirror.
• Incomplete Picture: 13Fs only show long positions in U.S. equities. They do not show:
  • Short positions: A manager might be long Ford but short GM as a pair trade. Seeing only the long position gives you a dangerously incomplete view.
  • International stocks: A manager might be selling U.S. banks to buy European banks, but you'll only see the selling.
  • Cash or other assets: You don't know their cash position or holdings in bonds, commodities, or private companies.
• No “Why”: The filing is pure data. It never explains the investment thesis. A manager might be buying a stock for reasons you would completely disagree with.
• The “Coattail” or “Cloning” Trap: The biggest pitfall is blindly copying. You don't know the average price the manager paid, you don't share their time horizon, and you won't know when they decide to sell. This is a recipe for poor returns.

• superinvestors_of_graham_and_doddsville
• due_diligence
• circle_of_competence
• margin_of_safety
• investment_thesis
• behavioral_finance
• information_vs_knowledge